Getting ready for Donald Trump

David Coates - Professor of Anglo-American Studies, Wake Forest University, North Carolina

The superficial Trump grasp on how to fix America’s current difficulties

Then there is the question of the skill-set that Donald Trump is proposing to bring to the presidency, should he be elected.  The way he tells it, the big problem of the current Administration – and indeed of many of his fellow aspirants for high office in the Republican Party – is their lack of negotiating skills.  The way he tells it, he would have got a better deal with Iran, and under his Presidency ISIS would already be defeated.  The way he tells it, he will be the ‘greatest jobs president that God ever created’.

There are at least two problems with his view of what is wrong with America, and how it is to be fixed.  The first is that it is exclusively and excessively an ‘agency’ explanation of what is currently going wrong.  It puts the entire explanatory focus on the skills of a single individual, rather than on the underlying ‘structures’ (institutions, groups and trends) to which those skills have to make a response.  The Trump solution to America’s current difficulties is in that sense a view of politics as magic.  Find a different wizard with a different wand, and hey presto, if the wizard’s magic is stronger than anyone else’s, the problems will all be quickly put to rest.

But America’s condition is not so simply analysed, let alone so simply solved.  On a global stage, the United States lives in a multi-polar world in which other actors have resources beyond America’s control, and a world in which American actions have long-term ramifications and push-back.  Abroad, unless Donald Trump is envisioning using nuclear weapons or launching a third large-scale American ground war, it is hard to see how simply replacing Obama with Trump will (as Trump promised) ‘make your head spin’.  And at home, the depth of the social divisions that now beset us, and the entrenched nature of the poverty and urban deprivation that surrounds and underpins increasingly insecure middle-class life, cannot be blasted away by the force of a President’s personality or by the immediate impact of new and so far unspecified policies, no matter what a bombastic Donald Trump might regularly claim.

The Trump propensity for bombast over policy

For here is the ultimate danger in the Trump candidacy: its propensity for bombast over policy, and its associated assertion of Donald Trump’s own superiority to anyone else currently holding or seeking political office.  This excessive degree of arrogance and self-belief shows itself mainly in the Trump determination to focus the campaign on personality and personal capacity, rather than on policy per se. The full Trump agenda of legislative proposals may eventually be forced out of him, but it is not there yet.  What we have instead is political theatre, regularly provided in grandstanding fashion for the attention of a flaccid media – grandstanding that, when it gets down to specifics, has so far only stirred some particularly unattractive mud.

The Trump demonisation of Mexican immigrants is the major case in point.  It legitimates and reinforces the very racial and ethnic stereotyping that is currently souring relationships between key groups of the American poor – between white, black and Hispanic Americans.  The linkage that Donald Trump regularly draws between immigration and crime is entirely false and profoundly dangerous.  Donald Trump is currently exploiting, for his own short-term political ends, the fears and insecurities of a predominantly white lower middle-class in contemporary America, galvanising their support by talking over and over again about immigrant criminals.  In doing so, he is not only failing to get to the heart of why certain kinds of crime are again on the rise in America.  He is also reinforcing the underlying racism that remains America’s key internal weakness and source of shame.

Those of us who live in America have the greatest cause to worry at the prospect of a Trump Presidency.  But, given the danger of an over-arrogant President sitting with his finger on the nuclear button, the rest of the world ought perhaps to worry too.